Skip to Main Content
NinetyPresents
A man stands in front of a group of people

Choosing Leaders People Want to Follow

When founders and CEOs promote someone into leadership, there’s usually solid reasoning behind their decision. They choose people who know the business well, consistently deliver strong work, have credibility in their craft, and are ready to take on more.

Then they're given a team. Sometimes it works beautifully. Other times, you learn that person’s performance told you very little about their ability to lead other human beings.

I’ve seen a lot of strong individual performers over the years who struggle once their success depends on helping other people succeed. That's why I've come to believe there’s a simple question every founder and CEO should ask before promoting someone into leadership:

Will good people choose to follow this person?

A title gives someone authority, but followership has to be earned.

Performance Isn't the Same as Leadership

When deciding who’s ready to lead, a lot of founders and senior leaders look to team members who display confidence, charisma, technical competence, and a strong record of delivering results. I understand why. Those qualities are visible, and they help people advance early in their careers. But leading people requires a different set of capabilities.

Someone can be exceptional at their craft and still struggle to develop others. They can hit every target they’re given without helping the people around them grow. They can step into a leadership Seat with enormous confidence and still fail to earn the trust of the team.

I recently sat down with leadership coach and author Marcel Schwantes who shared an example that illustrates this well. Earlier in his career, he worked in a command-and-control environment where his manager called most of the shots. Marcel rarely felt free to make decisions about his own work because he never knew whether taking initiative would lead to being reprimanded. He felt severe stress and anxiety in his role that led to serious health issues.

In his next role, his leader operated very differently. He spent time teaching Marcel, gave him assignments that stretched his abilities, stayed close enough to help him learn, and then trusted him to take ownership. Marcel became more engaged and more capable because someone believed he could grow.

That’s leadership. The best leaders don’t make themselves indispensable. They help other people become more capable.

Leadership Shows Up in the Team

If you want to know whether someone is ready to lead, look at the people around them. Are they learning? Are they taking more ownership? Do they understand what they’re accountable for? Do they trust this person enough to raise problems before they get bigger?

Those are better indicators of leadership than personal output alone. Strong leaders help capable people grow in their roles and become more confident in owning their work.

Of course, not every employee will thrive under every leader. Human beings are different, and every company needs people who fit both the culture and the Seats they occupy. But when the fit is right, a good leader should help people become better at what they do.

I deeply believe choosing leaders is one of the most important calls a founder makes. When someone steps into a leadership Seat, they’re being trusted with part of the company and with the development of the people who work with them. That deserves more thought than, “They’ve been one of our strongest performers.”

 

Nobody's going to follow a leader they can't trust.

Marcel Schwantes

Leadership Coach and Author

 

Trust Has to Be Earned

Marcel also told me about a company he worked with as a leadership coach. The company had brought in an accomplished CEO with a strong track record at much larger organizations. He came in with confidence and started making changes before spending much time understanding the people or how the company operated. Within two years, employee turnover was around 50%.

When Marcel presented exit interview data showing that the CEO was part of the problem, the CEO’s first response was to ask for the identities of the employees who had given the feedback. Marcel ultimately decided to part ways with the client, and the company closed several months later.

Plenty of factors contribute to whether a company succeeds or fails, so it isn't fair to pin that outcome on one person. But the example is a reminder that a Seat may give someone authority, but it can’t make people trust or follow them.

That’s one of the many reasons why culture is so important. If leaders are expected to earn trust, develop people, and produce results through their teams, a title can only take them so far.

4 Questions Before You Give Someone a Team

At Ninety, we spend a lot of time thinking about roles, accountabilities, and responsibilities (what we call RARs), and whether someone has what it takes to thrive in a particular Seat. Ninety helps leadership teams define what each Seat owns and what success looks like. That gives founders a clearer basis for evaluating who’s ready to lead, but the final decision is still theirs.

Before you promote someone to a leadership Seat, ask these questions:

  1. Do people become more capable around this person? Strong leaders teach, coach, and create opportunities for others to grow.

  2. Can this person create clarity without controlling every decision? Leadership requires setting agreements while still giving capable people room to own their work.

  3. Will this person deal directly with poor performance or damaging behavior? Caring about people includes being willing to address situations that are hurting the rest of the team or the company.

  4. Do people already trust this person? You don’t need a leadership title to earn trust. Look at whether colleagues seek out their perspective, want them involved in important work, and trust them to do what they say they’ll do.

You won’t know with certainty how someone will lead until you give them the Seat. That’s why promoting a leader is ultimately a judgment call, and one founders shouldn’t make based on performance alone.

Choose Leaders Worth Following

For me, the standard is a company where great people love the work they do, respect the people they do it with, and believe in building a company that can thrive for the long term. The leaders you choose have a lot to do with whether that becomes true.

So look beyond confidence and individual performance. Look for people who help others grow and give them room to own their work.

A title gives someone authority. Whether people choose to follow them is something they have to earn.

For more on this topic, listen to my Founder’s Framework episode with Marcel Schwantes, where we dig deeper into leadership, followership, courage, and caring for people while building a great company.

For more insights on building resilient, high-performing companies, subscribe to the Founder’s Framework newsletter.